The Great British Map; Or Great Britain vs. The United Kingdom vs. The British Isles

Last night I made another map. It tries to answer some of more perplexing and confusing facets of the geography surrounding the world’s 9th largest island. I mean of course Great Britain. No, wait. I mean the United Kingdom. No, wait. I mean Britain. Or do I mean England? See, it’s confusing.

  • So if the ISO 3166-2 code is GBR, how come the country is called the United Kingdom?
  • But if England is a country and the United Kingdom is a country, how come England is part of the United Kingdom?
  • What about Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland?

This isn’t the first time I’ve covered this topic. The first time was for a post on the now defunct Yahoo! Geo Technologies blog entitled UK Addressing, The Non Golden Rules Of Geo Or Help! My Country Doesn’t Exist. The ygeoblog.com domain is now long gone and redirects to the Yahoo! corporate blog but I was able to reproduce this post here and it’s also captured in the Internet Archive’s WayBackMachine. The second time was when I made a variation of The Great British Venn Diagram. But this is the first time (though probably not the last) that I’ve used a map, which is odd as this is something that’s tailor-made for a map.

I’d been looking for a good source of geographic vector data that I could use to easily overlay polygons on a map and came across a rich source of free vector and raster map data from Natural Earth. But instead of overlaying that data on top of a standard slippy map using a JavaScript maps API to tap into a tile server’s bitmap tiles, I soon wondered whether I could actually make a map from the vector data. It turned out I could and decided to revisit the structure of the group of islands I live on one more time and try to visualise the difference between Great Britain, the United Kingdom and the British Isles. The end result, punningly entitled the Great British Map, looks something like this …

Great British Map

When the page first loads you’ll see the coastlines of Britain, Ireland and towards the bottom, the Channel Islands. There’s then five ways of looking at this particular map.

There’s the group of geographic islands that’s termed the British Isles; these show up in purplish-grey and if you’re observant, the Channel Islands vanish as they’re not part of this island group.

Great British Map - Great Britain

Then there’s the individual geographic islands of Great Britain, Ireland, the Isle Of Man and The Channel Islands; these show up in green.

Great British Map - United Kingdom

There’s two sovereign states, The United Kingdom of Great Britain And Northern Island and the Republic Of Ireland; these show up in red.

Great British Map - England

Next comes the administrative countries which make up the United Kingdom; England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. These show up in yellow.

Great British Map - Crown Dependencies

Finally, there’s the Crown Dependencies, the self governing possessions of the British Crown; the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands are these and they show up as purple.

What’s missing from the map? The British Overseas Territories, which is a polite way of saying what’s left of the British Empire that didn’t gain independence and which the United Kingdom still asserts sovereignty over. These are Anguilla, Bermuda, British Antarctic Territory, British Indian Ocean Territory, British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Falkland Islands, Gibraltar, Montserrat, Pitcairn Islands, St. Helena, Ascension Island, Tristan da Cunha, the Sovereign Base Areas of Akrotiri and Dhekalia and the Turks and Caicos Islands.

If you’re interested in how I actually made the map, read on.

The source data from the map are two public domain datasets from Natural Earth; the 1:10m map Admin 0 Subunits dataset and the 1:10m Populated Places dataset. This data includes shapefiles which can be converted into GeoJSON format by the GDAL ogr2ogr command line tool. I extracted the vectors for the UK, Ireland, Isle of Man and Channel Islands from the Admin 0 Subunits dataset, keying on their ISO 3166-1 Alpha-3 country codes.

$ ogr2ogr -f GeoJSON -where "adm0_a3 IN ('GBR','IRL','IMN','GGY','JEY','GBA')" subunits.json ne_10m_admin_0_map_subunits/ne_10m_admin_0_map_subunits.shp

I then extracted the place data from the Populated Places dataset, again extracting data for the UK, Ireland, Isle of Man and Channel Islands, this time keying on their ISO 3166-1 Alpha-2 country codes. Not entirely sure why one dataset uses Alpha-2 and the other uses Alpha-3 but go figure; the data is free, accurate and open so who am I to complain?

$ ogr2ogr -f GeoJSON -where "iso_a2 IN ('GB','IM','JE','GG') AND SCALERANK < 8" places.json ne_10m_populated_places/ne_10m_populated_places.shp

Finally, I merged subunits.json and places.json into a single TopoJSON file, with the added bonus that TopoJSON is much much smaller than GeoJSON. The source GeoJSON weighed in at 549 KB whereas the combined TopoJSON is a mere 78 KB.

$ topojson --id-property su_a3 -p NAME=name -p name -o great-british-map.json subunits.json places.json

The main reason for use of TopoJSON is not that it’s much more lightweight than GeoJSON, but that Mike Bostock’s excellent D3 JavaScript library can easily slurp in TopoJSON and inject SVG straight into an HTML document. Which is precisely what the map’s underlying code does. There’s a lot more that D3 could do with this map, but it’s early days and for a first step into a new maps library, I’m pretty happy with how it’s turned out.

Speaking of code, it should come as no surprise that the map’s code base is available on GitHub. The Great British Map is based on great D3 tutorial that Mike has written on vector mapping using Natural Earth, so the similarity between Mike’s map and my map is entirely intentional.

Written and posted from home (51.427051, -0.333344)

7 Comments

  • I like this post. And I recall the previous ones.

    Before proper analysis and comment, can I ask if Fig 3. should show Republic of Ireland in red as per your caption [i.e.sovereign state] and Fig 4. should show Northern Ireland as yellow as per your caption [i.e. administrative country]?

    Or is it just ma computah?

    • Fig 3 is one of the sovereign state transitions, in this case the United Kingdom; hover over the Republic of Ireland link on the map itself and you’ll see Ireland (Republic Of) in red.

      Ditto for Fig 4; the screen-shot shows England, but there’s hover transitions for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland as the other administrative countries for the United Kingdom.

      It’s not your computah, it’s just the screen-shots only show one of multiple variants of the maps state.

      • Ah I see now thanks! Was only looking at the screen-shots.

        Worth noting that the term ‘The British Isles” is not used so much in the Republic of Ireland to describe the islands geographically anymore, simply because the term came into effect along with The British Empire, of which Ireland is no longer part of. Fact is, most Irish people and organisations are uncomfortable with the fact that it is still in use in geographical texts, and common vocabulary – despite Irish independence in the 1920s.

        And so began the search for an alternative. The term ‘Islands of the North Atlantic (or IONA)’ was introduced – adopted quickly within political circles, but not as heartily by scientists – largely because of its ambiguity in that it could also include other islands (i.e. the North Atlantic is a big place and has unclear boundaries).

        The ‘Western European Isles’ was another bandied about term, as is ‘The Pretanic Isles’ – a nod to the Greeks and their cartography of around 300BC. A couple of hundred years later, a Roman geographer, beautifully named as Pomponius Mela, christened the islands ‘Oceani Insulae’, Latin for ‘Islands of the Ocean’. But while the legal and religious profession hang on to Latin terms, geographers are less inclined.

        Another beauty is ‘The Northwest European Archipelago’. Bit of a mouthful that one – and the term would no doubt face the guillotine with the resulting acronym hardly a glittering addition to common vocabulary.

        The etymologist in me says keep the syllables to a minimum, i.e. if people are used to saying ‘The British Isles’ why not just swap ‘British’ with ‘Pretanic’ ? But then surely Britain would feel a bit toe-stepped by using an ancient Greek name, especially when the world is all about cherishing small nations, promoting national identity and moving away from imperialist symbols of the past.

        The debate coasts along without resolve.

        • To be cautioned with the usual “but I found it on the internet so it must be true”, Wikipedia has this to say

          The term British Isles is controversial in Ireland, where there are objections to its usage due to the association of the word British with Ireland. The Government of Ireland does not recognise or use the term and its embassy in London discourages its use. As a result, Britain and Ireland is used as an alternative description, and Atlantic Archipelago has had limited use among a minority in academia, although British Isles is the internationally recognised term.

          Things are a bit easier when it comes to nations, as you can point to ISO as the source of (political) truth, even then there’s the issue of politically and culturally accepted names; such as those in Cyprus and Taiwan. And that’s before you even get into contested territories.

          For now, as you say, the debate is yet to be resolved.

          For what it’s worth, the point of the map was to show what’s (in general) internationally accepted and not to inflame national tensions.

          • Quite the opposite – I think the map helps to quench any national tensions simply by dissecting and clarifying the terms of reference for these islands.

        • And on the topic of Islands of the North Atlantic, one can easily see how this would be oft abbreviated to IONA, which would, of course, get the UK government miffed, hack off the people of (the island of) Iona and cause even more confusion!

  • There’s also quite a fun video on Youtube explaining some of these differences too (it goes on to some of the various international territories too):
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNu8XDBSn10

    Jeremy